How Property is Valued
Each county appraisal district determines the value of all taxable property within the county boundaries. Tax Code Section 25.18 requires appraisal districts to reappraise all property in its jurisdiction at least once every three years. Tax Code Section 23.01 requires that appraisal districts comply with the Uniform Standards of Professional Appraisal Practice if mass appraisal is used and that the same appraisal methods and techniques be used in appraising the same or similar kinds of property. Individual characteristics that affect the property’s market value must be evaluated in determining the property’s market value.
Before appraisals begin, the appraisal district compiles a list of taxable property. The list contains a description and the name and address of the owner for each property. In a mass appraisal, the appraisal district then classifies properties according to a variety of factors, such as size, use and construction type. Using data from recent property sales, the appraisal district appraises the value of typical properties in each class. Taking into account differences such as age or location, the appraisal district uses typical property values to appraise all the properties in each class.
3 common approaches that the appraisal district may use in appraising property are the sales comparison (market) approach, the income approach and the cost approach.
The market approach to value is based on sales prices of similar properties. It compares the property being appraised to similar properties that have recently sold and then adjusts the comparable properties differences between them and the property being appraised.
The income approach is based on income and expense data and is used to determine the present worth of future benefits. It seeks to determine what an investor would pay now for a future revenue stream anticipated to be received from the property.
The cost approach is based on what it would it cost to replace the building (improvement) with one of equal utility. Depreciation is applied and the estimate is added to the land value.
Problems:
- Sales tax has been declining and corporate loopholes continues
- Loopholes in Texas tax and expenditure limits to avoid paying taxes
- Tax increment financing is a way for companies to avoid paying taxes
- Texas is a non disclosure state
- Texas does not have a real estate transfer tax
- Commercial real estate owners have the resources to use legal loopholes in the appraisal system
- Reducing the roll back rate for local Texas governments from 8% to 4% is not property tax reform
Solutions:
- Expand medicaid
- Amend the the Texas constitution to allow the counties to collect attorney’s fees if they win in court to discourage frivolous appeals
- Require real estate sales price to be public
- Establishing a state-financed legal defense fund for counties facing appraisal lawsuits
- Create a state public bank
- Reform TIRZ
- Create a roperty tax circuit breaker and do a pilot study with 2 to 3 counties
- Amend the Texas Constitution (A3) from median value to market value
- Amend the Texas constitution to close the corporate loopholes for golf courses
- Amend the Texas constitution (a-1) to lower the market value to $500,000 for homeowners that protest appraisals
Texas Constitution
Code – Tax Code
Chapter – 23 Appraisal Methods and Procedures
Section – 23.01
Section – 23.81 Subchapter F. Appraisal of Recreational, Park and Scenic Land
Chapter – 25 Local Appraisal
Section – 25.18 Periodic Appraisal
Chapter – 26 Assessment
Section – 26.04 Submission of Roll to Governing Body; Effective and Rollback Tax Rates
Chapter – 42 Judicial Review
Section 42.26 Remedy for Unequal Appraisal
Chapter – 41 Local Review
Section – 41.43 Protest of Determination of Value or Inequality of Appraisal
Code – Government Code
Chapter – 403 Comptroller of Public Accounts
Section – 403.302 Determination of School District Property Values
Code – Texas Constitution
Article – 8 Taxation and Revenue
Section – 1 Equality and Uniformity; Tax in Proportion to Value: Income Tax; Exemption of Certain Tangible Personal Property from Ad Valorem Taxation
Code – Tax Code
Chapter – 42 Judicial Review
Chapter – 42.26 Remedy for Unequal Appraisal
Slate – These Graphs Explain Why California’s Property-Tax Regime Is the Worst
Statesman – PolitiFact: Texas property taxes high, but burden varies
Statesman – Commentary: Texas Constitution is not a loophole
Statesman – Appeals shift tax burden
Statesman – Property tax bill with far-reaching consequences had hidden beginning
Texas Tribune – Sales Price Disclosure Debate May Take a Turn in Texas
Texas Tribune – Cable and Satellite Providers Square Off Over Tax Break
Texas Tribune – Property Tax Relief Comes With Big Cost to State
Texas Tribune – Bettencourt Hopes to Slow Property Tax Growth
Texas Tribune – Lawmakers Want Property Tax Cut That Folks Notice
Texas Tribune – Loser-Pays Bill Clears Texas House
Austin Business Journal – Texans to fight to keep sales prices of land, homes and offices private
Missoula Realtors lukewarm on proposed real estate sale price disclosure bill
Dallas News – Dallas Country Club sues appraisal district for eighth time
Dallas News – Six lawsuits from Dallas Country Club shaved $15 million off property values
Dallas News – Editorial: Sales price disclosure needed for transparent taxes
Dallas News – Should Lowe’s ‘dark store’ strategy in Texas concern D-FW taxpayers?
Dallas News – Tax law leads to towering savings for big building owners
Dallas News – Level Texas’ property tax playing field
My San Antonio – Mandatory Real Estate Sales Price Disclosure
My San Antonio – Property tax loophole could drive down values, appraiser says
My San Antonio – Property tax fight misses the point
My San Antonio – Patrick’s Bexar property tax analysis is faulty
NPR – Reporter’s Notebook: How to Get Information in a Non-Disclosure State
NPR – Teed Up: Slicing Texas Tax Breaks
Billings Gazette – Director says real estate sales prices should be public
Texas Monthly – The Taxing Issue of Rollbacks
CPPP – Have Property Taxes Gone Up, Really?
CBPP – Without A State Income Tax, Other Taxes Are Higher
CBPP – The Problems with Property Tax Revenue Caps
CPPP – Circuit breakers: The Best Way to Control Property Taxes
New York Times – State by State Property Tax Rates
New York Times – The Joys of No Income Tax, the Agonies of Other Kinds
Houston Independent School District Tax Rate
Texas tax code loopholes State tax exemptions need to be reviewed.
Harris County keeps property tax rate even but bills may rise
Lincoln Institute of Land Policy – 50 State Property Tax Comparison Study
Caller Times – Tax code amendment costs schools millions
Beaumont Enterprise – Valero, BASF, Total protest in ‘ongoing’ property tax battle
Texas Public Radio – The Source: Constitutional Right Or Abused Loophole?
Houston Chronicle – Bill would require super majority to pass local tax hikes
Houston Chronicle – Another story on the huge inequities of our property tax system
Houston Chronicle – Marathon settles suit with Galveston County appraisal district
Houston Chronicle – 7 things to know about a costly tax ‘loophole’
Houston Chronicle – Texas property taxes among the nation’s highest
Houston Chronicle – County to drop challenge of HCAD’s methods
Houston Chronicle – Some tax breaks have become par for the course
Houston Chronicle – Texas tax code loopholes
Houston Chronicle – H-E-B, Walgreens file suit against Jefferson County Appraisal District
Texas Municipal League – Proposed “Tax Cuts” and What They Might Mean for Cities
League of Women Voters Texas – Financing State Government; The Budget and Taxes
Texas Observer – Instead of Tax Breaks for Yacht Owners, How About Closing Corporate Loopholes?
Waco Tribune – Local government funds at stake as Riesel coal plant sues over value
Houston Press – Shakedown: The HCAD Appraisal Game
Longview New Journal – Titus power plant Luminant in suit over tax appraisals
Public Citizen – Expose Corporations That Are Rigging the Justice System Against Consumers
Wall Street Journal – Why Data Centers Collect Big Tax Breaks
Bloomberg – Texas Cities Are Worried Republicans Pushed Tax Cuts Too Far
Texas Monthly – What Happened to the Property Tax Cut?
Governing – Big-Box Stores Battle Local Governments Over Property Taxes
News Week – This California Property Tax Loophole Must Be Fixed
Progress Texas – My Tax Dollars Pay for WHAT?!?!
Texas Association of Counties – Heavy Equipment Tax Loophole Being Exploited
Community Impact Newspaper – Katy area property values continue to rise at an average of 3-8 percent
The Atlantic – The Folly of State Level Tax Cuts
Star Telegram – Tarrant property owners: Five things to know about filing a protest
New York Times – Texas May Consider a Bill Forcing Losers in a Suit to Pay Opponents’ Legal Fees
San Antonio Current – Big Box Chain Brings “Dark Store” Tax Dodge to San Antonio
San Antonio Current – Valero Court Case Could Mean Higher Property Taxes for San Antonio Homeowners
The Anniston Star – Calhoun County court consolidates Lowe’s property tax cases